We dug through all of the Amish serial killers that we could find and chose the cream of the crop to present to you today. Actually, it was a quick search since he is the ONLY Amish serial killer in history. Kent gets graphic. The Op goes green. This one has rubber toys, fire, bullets, and buttons... beautiful, ornate, forbidden buttons. Enjoy.

Ad-free episodes, hours of extra content each week, exclusive merch, and early access to all of the 11:59 Media podcasts. Start accessing hundreds of additional hours! Visit 11:59 PLUS.