the Digital Collective

Embrace the Trifecta - Shorts, Longform, and Live Community


Listen Later

“We need $2 from everyone so James can ship this dang mug.”

That one line set the tone. A live stream, a packed chat, and a running joke about an $83.95 shipping fee to send a ceramic coffee mug from California to the UK. People laughed. People gave. And the room felt alive.

That small, funny moment reminded everyone why live video works. It’s real. It’s messy. It’s human. And when the community rallies, even a mug gets its moment.

Melanie states, “…I’m easing my way back into streaming after a long break. Gear was in totes, cameras unplugged, and more cords than sense. But I missed the conversation — the unscripted moments, the people in the chat, the chance to be human-to-human. If you’re thinking about getting back in or just trying to make your creator time count, here’s the approach that’s working for me: focus on the trifecta, protect the experience while you monetize, and design interactions that build culture, not noise.”

The Trifecta: Short Form, Long Form, and Live

The content trifecta is simple and non-negotiable if you want momentum: short form (discoverability), long form (depth and subscribers), and live (community and connection). Each serves a distinct purpose in the funnel.

* Short form — Reels, Shorts, micro-clips. Top-of-funnel discovery. Pull the best two-minute nuggets from longer sessions and publish them where new people hang out.

* Long form — Edited, produced episodes that show depth and keep people subscribing. This is where you explain ideas, build trust, and convert casual viewers into fans.

* Live — The place to be raw, responsive, and relational. Live is where culture forms; viewers become participants and the audience helps make the show.

I believe in doing all three, but you don’t have to perfect every channel overnight. Experiment widely, then narrow in once you know where your people are and how they like to engage.

Monetization: Respect the Experience

Ads and monetization are part of the creator economy. You should be paid for your work, but consider timing. Ads that interrupt a live conversation frustrate viewers and break the flow.

One practical tactic: turn ads off while you’re live and switch monetization back on immediately after the stream ends. That keeps the live experience clean and preserves the post-live revenue opportunity.

Multi-Aspect Streaming: Vertical vs Horizontal

Platforms are trying to serve both quick-consumption vertical audiences and longer-form horizontal audiences simultaneously. That sounds great in theory, but it creates two different viewer experiences — and therefore two separate comment streams.

If you’re streaming to both vertical and horizontal feeds, you need a plan for each. Vertical is optimized for quick consumption — think TikTok or Instagram-style attention. Horizontal still wins for long-form conversation and comment engagement.

* Vertical: bold visuals, tight framing, quick hooks. Comments can feel sparse and lonely compared to horizontal.

* Horizontal: room for overlays, comments, richer production elements, and fuller audience interaction.

As a producer, this multiplies configuration work. As a creator, think about where your core community lives and which format serves them best. If you’re starting, cast a wider net. If you’re established, pick one home base and make it great.

Substack and the Newsletter-as-Platform

Newsletters have evolved. Substack in particular is no longer just email — it’s becoming a social layer, podcast host, and even a live destination. You can push livestreams to Substack, embed videos in posts, and host premium tiers for people who want to comment and interact more deeply.

Why this matters:

* Control — You own your list and can create gated experiences without building complex tech.

* Proof of authenticity — Embedding short, raw video clips inside a written post adds human proof that you are the person behind the content.

* Monetization options — Substack takes a cut of paid subscriptions, but it handles payments, tiers, and distribution.

Production: Keep It Scrappy, Not Crappy

High production value helps, but content and energy win. Pat McAfee didn’t become a phenomenon by upgrading every camera; he did it by staying authentic, consistent, and building a show people care about.

Be scrappy. Just don’t be crappy.

Practical lighting and camera tips that won’t break the bank:

* Use a simple three-point setup: key light, soft fill, and a subtle hair or backlight to separate you from a dark background.

* Control hot spots. If your forehead or scalp catches too much light, try lowering intensity, diffusing the light, or using a light grid to direct output.

* A little mattifying powder or anti-shine product is a creator hack for reducing glare on camera.

* Keep background practicals (lamps, RGB bulbs) subtle so the set feels moody without distracting the viewer.

Community and Culture: The Real Competitive Moat

Community isn’t just about numbers. It’s about culture. The way you moderate comments, which comments you surface, and how you respond shapes the environment people want to return to. Live video is the most powerful place to build culture because it creates back-and-forth connection in real time.

Small audiences can be intimate and powerful. Learn names, call people out when appropriate, and reward contribution. If your community grows large, gated or paid rooms are a natural next step for bringing intimacy back.

Examples of community strategies

* Host a public 30-minute live and then a 20-minute members-only deep dive.

* Clip the best live moments into short-form content for discovery, and link back to the longform episode or newsletter post.

* Use merch or small gestures (signed items, shoutouts) to reinforce belonging.

Simple Checklist to Return to Live (or Start One)

* Decide your home base platform: where will the majority of your community experience you?

* Map the trifecta: plan one longform episode, three short clips, and one live session per week or month.

* Set monetization rules: ads off during live, ads on after; or enable memberships for exclusive interaction.

* Optimize minimal production: key light, hair light, subtle background color, and a microphone that picks up voice cleanly.

* Capture and clip: use an automatic clipping tool or your recording setup to pull shared short-form assets post-stream.

* Schedule an outreach cadence: newsletter, social posts, and short clips to funnel viewers into the live room.

Parting Thought

Getting back into streaming doesn’t require a full studio overhaul. Show up, be human, and keep the experience respectful for the people who choose to spend time with you. Start scrappy, iterate quickly, and protect the moments that matter. If you do that consistently, the rest — discovery, subscribers, and revenue — follow as feedback that you’re on the right path.

Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app.



Get full access to the Digital Collective at digitalcollective.media/subscribe
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

the Digital CollectiveBy James Hicks