A wine collection can look like a hobby until it lands in a divorce, an estate fight, or a federal case. Then every bottle needs a defensible value, a paper trail, and an explanation that makes sense to people who have never read a wine list in their lives. We sit down with Melissa Smith, founder of Enotrias Elite Sommelier Services, to talk about wine collection appraisal, expert witness testimony, and the real-world mechanics of treating wine as a legal asset.

Melissa walks us through how she went from fine dining to becoming the person attorneys call when inventories, valuations, and credibility matter. We dig into what she now asks on the first phone call, what she deliberately holds back, and why scope and boundaries protect both the expert and the client. We also get specific about expert witness contracts, a simple rate structure, and why a nonrefundable retainer can be the difference between a clean engagement and months of chaos.