In June of 1996 Darlie, Darin, Devon, Damon, and Drake Routier appeared to be living the American Dream. That dream quickly turned into a nightmare one fateful night when an attacker came into the home and brutally murdered Devon and Damon.

Was this a sick killer? A robbery gone wrong? Or a mother gone ballistic?

Many think Darlie is innocent. After listening to the episode, let us know what you think.