This week on Ty & That Guy, Wes Chatham and Ty Franck dive headfirst into the gory, glorious chaos of The Substance—a shocking and stylish descent into body horror with sharp teeth and even sharper social commentary. The guys unpack the film’s bold vision, the insane practical effects, and the fearless central performance that’s already stirring up awards-season buzz.

But what really grabs Ty and Wes is the comeback factor. With The Substance, Demi Moore storms back into the spotlight with a role that’s raw, risky, and unforgettable. That performance got the crew thinking: what are the greatest comeback roles of all time? From actors who vanished for a decade to those who reinvented themselves in one perfect part, the guys share their personal top 5 comeback performances.