When we say messy, we don't mean to diminish the importance of any topic. We are acknowledging that these topics are fraught with controversy, debate, and sensitivity. And yet, we realize we must discuss then in spite of the uncomfortableness if we are in fact to achieve collective liberation. Therefore, a topic that we want to approach and sift through the messiness of is antisemitism. We use an article from The Atlantic to unpack the public rhetoric surrounding this topic hoping to lend some nuance to the issue.