Matt and Bob kick off 2026 by breaking down Marty Supreme, Josh Safdie’s relentless, anxiety-fueled ride, and why Timothée Chalamet might be giving his best performance yet. They then slow it way down for Sentimental Value, a raw, sharply written family drama about art, legacy, and whether creativity heals or harms the people closest to us. Along the way they hit Chicago winter misery, Critics Choice/Oscar chatter, wild casting choices, and tease the upcoming ANALYSIS Awards (the ANALS)