What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi are feeling the love this Valentine’s Day, but these Redditors are not so lucky. Is it just a clueless gym bro who had a little too much creatine? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out!

Follow our subreddit at r/WhatWasThat_thepod, follow on Tik Tok at @whatwasthat_thepod, find us on YouTube, or email us at [email protected]

If you’d like to share your own story, please be sure to message us!

Music by: 

Leonell Cassio