Welcome back to Mary Sue, Who? In the first part of this week's two-part episode, Kristin and Toni reveal each of their top 5 (possibly controversial) book boyfriend lists, including many popular love interests. How does your list compare?

*Spoilers for ACOTAR series: 7:40 - 18:40; 44:55 - 45:05

Throne of Glass series: 41:50 - 44:10

Kingdom of the Wicked: 57:33 - 57:40