When Natalee arrived on the island of Aruba with her fellow graduates on May 26th, 2005, she was looking forward to some days filled with sun, parties, and a good time. But when she failed to catch her flight home to Alabama on May 30th, a search for the missing teen quickly started. What came next were years filled with many suspects, searches, false confessions, and even a seemingly unrelated heinous crime. Join me as we take a closer look at the investigation and try to make sense of it all.