In the first official episode for the Middle Aged Sports Spectacular the boys discuss their picks for MVP, Most Improved Player, Cy Young, Coach of the Year, and Rookie of the Year. Dave botches his first attempt at hosting, Pat can't get enough of Sonny Gray and Rocco Baldelli, Doug makes logical picks for nearly every award, and Pepe draws boos from the crowd (mostly from Pat) with his pick for AL MVP.