Halloween is creeping in on Between 2 Butts! Episode 11 begin with a review of Hocus Pocus from a first-time viewer and stories about Hocus Pocus cosplay. THis ends up as a discussion on the proper spelling of Bryan/Brian. Keeping on the costumes theme, Becca talks about gender-bent cosplay, including her own adventures dressing up as male characters. October also marks the 70th anniversary of "Peanuts", as well as the Peanuts Halloween special, so Tice shares a list of Peanuts characters who disappeared, including one that Charles Schulz...sort of murdered? Jay is up third and the spookiest thing he has for us is an unpopular opinion: that Karate Kid 2 was better than the first movie. Becca is still working on her Cobra Kai "Cawwwww!" sound effect. To wrap up, we play "Cotton Candy Chicken Nuggets", and if you want to find out what THAT is, you have to listen to the end.