Hosts Drew and Kimmie return after a break to explore the Keddie Cabin murders, an unsolved quadruple homicide that rocked a tiny Northern California resort community in April 1981.

This episode introduces the Sharp and Smartt families, key suspects, and the initial crime scene details—bound victims, blunt-force trauma, and puzzling evidence pointing to premeditation.

Part one sets the stage for a three-part series that unpacks the case, the people involved, and unanswered questions that still haunt Keddie.