Jim is joined by NFL writer at CBS Sports, Jeff Kerr, to breakdown down the resume of former NFL quarterback Donovan McNabb. First, Jeff and Jim cover the 2002 Eagles game against the Cardinals where McNabb threw 4 TD passes despite playing on a broken ankle (4:16). Next, they compare McNabb to other great QBs that never won a Super Bowl, such as Fran Tarkenton and Jim Kelly, talk through McNabb's lack of All-Pro appearances, and break down where McNabb ranks among the best QBs of the 2000s (15:40). Finally, Jim and Jeff discuss McNabb's membership in the 5+ Championship Game Club (26:55), before they both make a final call on whether or not they believe McNabb deserves to gain entry into the Pro Football Hall of Fame (31:30).