Rolling Stones magazine called this episode "Provocatively entertaining, Benji and Jake take you on a journey of the mind that will leave you believing things you never thought possible and doubting things you thought were undoubtable. Imagine taking all the wisdom of the Bible, or any holy book for that manner, and changing the setting to something a little more aquatic. THAT is what this episode of North and Goal feels like. Actually it's two episodes, so there's that."