It seemed almost impossible, but in the years since our first couple of Charity - Nick and Florence - were wed, they dissolved their union. How and why did they break up? We look back in time at the history of their relationship, reliving some of our most memorable season two moments and seeing all new ones to get a deeper look at what happened between our favorite couple.

This brand new arc features our very first self-written RPG "Broken: a tragic romance game" to tell the story. Huge thanks to Blaine Martin who has consulted with Ben in developing this brand new two-player break-up game.

Sylvia also returns to appraise a very special box from Nick and Flo's past.

If you want to learn more about Nick and Flo's history, go back to episode 61: Welcome to Charity, Maine where their story began.

Theme song by Joe Marston. Additional music in this episode are the songs Mockingbird, Twinkle Twinkle, Summer Girls, and Ball and Chain by David Mumford used by CC 4.0 International license.