
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


The tophet debate is ongoing and technical. Listeners who want to dig into it should start with Quinn's In Search of the Phoenicians for a skeptical view of the sacrifice interpretation, and Xella et al. in Antiquity (2013) for the strongest recent case for sacrifice. The Oxford University press release (2014) on Quinn, Vella, and collaborators is freely available online and gives a readable summary of the archaeological evidence. The truth is that the debate is not fully resolved, and honesty requires saying so.
By Hugo PrudentiusThe tophet debate is ongoing and technical. Listeners who want to dig into it should start with Quinn's In Search of the Phoenicians for a skeptical view of the sacrifice interpretation, and Xella et al. in Antiquity (2013) for the strongest recent case for sacrifice. The Oxford University press release (2014) on Quinn, Vella, and collaborators is freely available online and gives a readable summary of the archaeological evidence. The truth is that the debate is not fully resolved, and honesty requires saying so.