Current Thoughts

Episode 15: Cruise Loyalty Programs – Carnival vs Royal Caribbean

Listen Later

Episode Title: Cruise Loyalty Programs: Carnival vs Royal Caribbean

Published: 7/2/2025

Episode Summary:

In this episode of Current Thoughts, D and J break down the loyalty programs of two major cruise lines: Royal Caribbean and Carnival. They explain how each program works, what perks are actually worth it, and the surprising changes coming to Carnival's new “Carnival Rewards” system. Whether you're a casual cruiser or a die-hard loyalist, this episode will help you decide where to spend your next vacation dollars—and why some cruisers are jumping ship.

Topics Covered:

  • How cruise line loyalty programs work and who benefits most
  • Breakdown of Royal Caribbean’s Crown & Anchor Society tiers and perks
  • Carnival’s current VIFP program vs the upcoming Carnival Rewards
  • Key differences in how loyalty status is earned: nights vs dollars
  • What the new changes mean for families, especially kids
  • Common cruiser frustrations about losing earned status
  • Real talk on which cruise line gives better value and perks
  • Can you really “buy” cruise loyalty?
  • Reactions from the cruise community and how Carnival might adjust
  • How status matching from other cruise lines may affect loyalty

    • Key Takeaways:

    • Royal Caribbean offers more compelling drink perks at mid-tier levels
    • Carnival’s new program bases status on spending, not cruise nights
    • Many longtime cruisers are upset about the ability to lose status
    • Kids under 18 earning elite status is a controversial topic
    • Status with Carnival will now have a 2-year expiration if not maintained
    • Royal Caribbean’s top-tier status requires far more cruising—making it feel more exclusive
    • If perks and status matter to you, it’s worth comparing both systems before booking

      • Connect With Us:

      • Instagram: ⁠@thereallifedandj⁠
      • YouTube: ⁠The Real Life with D&J⁠
      • Website: ⁠thereallifedandj.com⁠
      • Support the Show: ⁠Buy Us a Coffee⁠
      • ⁠Join us on Substack⁠

        • Join the Conversation:

        Are you loyal to a cruise line? What do you think of Carnival’s new rewards system? Has a loyalty perk ever swayed your booking decision? Let us know on Instagram or YouTube—we’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences.

        Thanks for tuning in! If this episode helped clarify the cruise loyalty maze, share it with your fellow cruisers and join us again for more honest, helpful conversations at sea and beyond.

        ...more
        View all episodesView all episodes
        Download on the App Store
        Current ThoughtsBy The Real Life with D & J