From Bloody Mary in your bathroom mirror to phantom phone calls from inside the house, these Halloween legends aren’t just spooky—they’re cultural staples. In this episode, Casey and Dave dig into the eerie origins and evolution of some of the most iconic urban legends of the season, including Bloody Mary, The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs, The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, and Detroit’s fiery Devil’s Night.

We’ll explore where these stories came from, why they spread like wildfire, and how they still manage to creep us out decades (or centuries) later.