Episode 151 Judgment / In the Pale Moonlight

We cover the much loved and semi controversial turning point in the Dominion War where Sisko gets his hands dirty on DS9. And on Enterprise we cover Scott Bakula's Favorite episode which does homage (or ripoff?) Star Trek 6. Judgment Ratings: Bob 6, Eric 7. In the Pale Moonlight Ratings: Bob 10, Eric 10.

Question: Do you feel Sisko did the right thing with his actions? Does this episode betray Roddenberry's vision of Star Trek?