In celebration of Buffy the Vampire Slayers 20th anniversary, the women of Underwire are professing their love/hate relationship with a show we once thought annihilated the patriarchy. The popular American TV series turned comic book, now on its 11th season, has been known for its unequivocally feminist ideals and putting women first. However, like many hit TV shows, Buffy failed in many ways to represent a diverse and intersectional cast. ToFemCo members Kaylee and Virginia address several issues we unveiled in one of our favourite TV chronicles, and how we came to acknowledge our enjoyment of something problematic.