Amanda and Sarah do Halloween right with a festive true crime case and a harrowing haunting. Amanda fills your candy bag up with the story of Peter Fabiano, aka the Trick or Treat Murder. Sarah unveils part one of a two-parter about the Mary Ellen Spook Farm of Caledonia Mills. Other subjects covered include impersonating Jennifer Coolidge, slipping into Scorpio season, and inventing a new milk. 

Recommendations:

Amanda recommends the new Unsolved Mysteries season on Netflix, and the Netflix anthology series Cabinet of Curiosities. Sarah does not recommend the movie Antlers. 

Sources:

• Fire Spook, the Mysterious Nova Scotia Haunting by Monica Grahaham. Nimbus Publishing Limited, 2013
• The Lineup (A Haunting at Caledonia Mills: The Chilling Case of the Mary Ellen Spook Farm)
• "My Experiences at the MacDonald Homestead" by H. B. Whidden
• Daily News (The Trick or Treat Murder)
• Vice (The Bizarre Lesbian Murder Scandal That Rocked 1950s LA)
• Newspapers.com (Lansing State Journal)

For updates on future episodes and other fun stuff, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, or check out our Patreon.