My trifecta of boyhood cinematic crushes would be Lori Loughlin, Phoebe Cates, and the lead in the movie we watched this week, Elisabeth Shue.  Whether or not Shue's girl-next-door charm can keep Adventures in Babysitting from aging badly is up for debate in this episode.  I probably should have just let this one remain a fairly good movie in my memory instead of risking the revisit, but all my picks ultimately run that risk.