Alex and Caitlin talk bad improv and then take an illuminating and magical journey through Caitlin's OK Cupid inbox, bringing them to the story of a woman who got her car stolen by a man she met on the very same website. Other topics include: A Florida man who Gone Girl'd his neighbor, a crime-by-egging that refuses to be solved, and a Hall and Oates edition of Old Man Yells At Cloud. This episode is part of a well-balanced breakfast.