Episode 19 – The Circleville Letters: Secrets, Scandals, and a Town on Edge

In the late 1970s, the small town of Circleville, Ohio, was struck by a wave of anonymous letters that exposed secrets, accused residents of crimes, and threatened violence. The writer — or writers — seemed to know everything about everyone. When a school bus driver became the primary target, a man was mysteriously killed, and a booby-trapped sign nearly ended in tragedy.

One man went to prison. But the letters didn’t stop.

In this episode of The Midnight Mystery Archive, we investigate the Circleville Letters case — one of America’s most bizarre unsolved mysteries. Was it a single stalker? A conspiracy? A community unraveling from the inside out? Decades later, the truth remains buried… somewhere between the mailbox and the grave.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #TheCircelvilleLetters #UnexplainedDisappearances #MysteryPodcast #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #OhioUnsolved #OhioMysteries