This time, we’re talking about the pop culture that surprised us: the movies, shows, music, games, and other things we expected to bounce off of but somehow ended up loving. Each host brings a lock, a swing pick, and an edge pick — but nobody knows what the others picked until the conversation starts. The result is a round of unexpected confessions, gentle judgment, and a few “wait, you liked that?” moments. Sometimes taste changes; sometimes the thing just wins you over against your will.

Have a take we missed? A topic we should tackle? A pick so obvious we’ll be embarrassed we forgot it? Email us at [email protected].

Like the show? You can support us on Buy Me a Coffee — or buy us a beer — with a one-time donation or a monthly membership. Memberships start at $2/month and include perks like our newsletter, bonus episodes, topic polls, shout-outs, and behind-the-scenes extras.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.