It's October 2000 - when butterfly clips were everywhere, friends were swapping burned CD's, and you couldn't use the house phone while someone was online. But in Lubbock, Texas, 14 year old Sarah Rogers never made it home.

In this episode, Jordyn and Alyssa rewind to the early 2000's. A time of dial-up tones, and TRL countdowns - to revisit one of Lubbock's tragic true crime cases.

So grab your wired headphones, log off AIM, and ask yourself... what the hell was going on?