This episode brings a true lose-lose dilemma: would you rather relive the exact same day forever while being fully aware of it, or wake up every day with no memory of your life like in 50 First Dates?

What starts as a movie-inspired question quickly turns into a deep (and slightly depressing) discussion about meaning, relationships, memory, identity, and whether ignorance might actually be better than awareness. Also: how long would it take before you'd go completely insane?