The World Model Podcast.

EPISODE 20: The Limits of the Knowable - When Simulation Fails


Listen Later

Welcome back. Throughout this season, we have been champions for the power of World Models. We've explored their potential to revolutionize science, industry, and even our understanding of reality. But today, we must perform a vital intellectual duty: we must explore their limits. For any tool, understanding its boundaries is as important as understanding its capabilities. There are fundamental reasons why a perfect, complete World Model of our universe may be forever beyond our reach.The first and most famous limit is chaos. Many systems in nature are exquisitely sensitive to initial conditions—the so-called 'butterfly effect.' While a World Model might be able to simulate a chaotic system in the short term, its long-term predictions are inherently impossible. The tiniest error in measuring the current state, a rounding error in the tenth decimal place, will lead to a completely different future. This means that perfect prediction of the weather, the stock market, or any complex social system is not a question of computational power; it is mathematically forbidden.Then there is the quantum world. At the subatomic scale, the universe is not deterministic. It is probabilistic. Events like radioactive decay are fundamentally random. You can know the probability, but you can never predict the exact moment of decay for a single atom. Any World Model that hopes to simulate reality at its most fundamental level must therefore incorporate genuine randomness. Its predictions would be ensembles of possibilities, not single, determined outcomes. This inherent indeterminacy is built into the fabric of reality.But perhaps the most profound limit is the problem of unknown unknowns. A World Model is trained on data from the world we have observed. It can interpolate and extrapolate from that data. But it cannot invent entirely new physics, new forces, new dimensions of existence that we have never encountered. If a 'black swan' event occurs that operates on principles outside our current scientific understanding, the model will be blind to it. It can simulate known risks, but it cannot simulate the truly alien.This has a crucial implication for the pursuit of AGI. It suggests that all intelligence, artificial or natural, operates with useful approximations. Our human brains are not perfect World Models of the universe. They are efficient, lossy compression algorithms that model the aspects of reality relevant to our survival and reproduction. We see a narrow band of light, hear a narrow range of sounds. Our internal model is full of cognitive biases and blind spots. But it is good enough.A superintelligent AI would likely face the same constraints. It might have a much better, much wider model, but it would still be a model. It would still have to make trade-offs between accuracy and computational cost. It would still be vulnerable to Gödelian incompleteness and the problem of induction.My controversial take is that the dream of a perfectly accurate, omniscient AI is a fantasy. There will always be a horizon of the unknowable. The universe may contain truths that are uncomputable, in the same way that there are numbers that are uncomputable. The ultimate World Model may not be a perfect reflection of reality, but simply the most useful and powerful approximation that is computationally possible.This is not a reason for despair, but for humility. It means that surprise, discovery, and the mystery of existence are not temporary conditions to be solved by better technology. They are permanent features of a complex, chaotic, and fundamentally uncertain cosmos. Our World Models will get astoundingly better, but they will never be finished.And this brings us to a fundamental question about the nature of these models. If they are approximations, where do they come from? In our next episode, we will argue that a true World Model cannot be built from data alone. It requires a body to interact with the world. It requires embodiment.
...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The World Model Podcast.By World Models