In this episode, Sin-Wang and Virginia Parker (University of St Andrews) discuss Virginia's experience as a peer reviewer for an international journal. They explore the challenges and benefits of peer review, the importance of being dialogic and relational in feedback, and the role of artificial intelligence in academic writing. Virginia shares her insights on the need for transparency and ethical use of AI in peer review. She also encourages doctoral researchers to embrace the opportunity to engage in peer review and contribute to the scholarly community.