Millions have binged 'S-Town,' the new podcast from 'Serial' and 'This American Life,' and H. Alan and Margot are no different.

Was there a murder? Did John have gold? Is this even true crime? What about Tyler? So many questions. We respond, review, react, question, and ponder: Who is John McLemore?

WARNING: This episode contains 'S-Town Podcast' SPOILERS!

Listen to every episode of 'S-Town' at stownpodcast.org.

Follow us at facebook.com/talkingcrime and twitter.com/talkingcrimepod.

Follow @HAlanScott and @MargotLeitman.

Donate at patreon.com/talkingcrime.

Stay safe!