For Keaton's birthday, Josh decides to give him the gift of closure, by addressing his co-host status and his membership to The Four Club.

SPOILER ALERT: Okay there is a spoiler for this episode below but I want to make sure you have a good opportunity not to see it because if it's right beside the words SPOILER ALERT then how can I reasonably expect you to see SPOILER ALERT but not see the actual spoiler. Anyway here's the spoiler - Christin (@misandrism) and Matt (@Mister_Veritas) are alsoin the episode.