In this episode, we welcome Jeff Jellison, the coroner for Hamilton County, to discuss the forensic challenges of the Fox Hollow Farm case, the science behind identifying remains in complex crime scenes, and the mysteries that linger decades later. From the legal limitations of classifying Baumeister as a serial killer to the psychological profile behind his crimes, we take a deep dive into what forensic evidence reveals about one of Indiana’s most disturbing cases.

Fox Hollow Farm holds a dark place in true crime history as the former home of Herb Baumeister, a suspected serial killer linked to the disappearance and murder of at least 11 men in the 1990s. The secluded property in Hamilton County, Indiana, became the site of one of the most chilling crime investigations in modern history—yet questions still remain. Were all of Baumeister’s victims ever identified? Could there be undiscovered remains still hidden on the property? And did he really act alone?