In this week's episode of We Don't Even Know, Shonali and Christian are joined by the hilarious John Early whom they recently saw starring in the Witchelor live (here's the trailer on Youtube). They discuss everything from male manicured hair, Neil Young at Red Rocks, guilty pleasures while working out, topless in NYC, being chubby, the Witchelor, Toni Collette, air guitaring poorly, Mike Tyson on Broadway, making out lots, and a new song by K. Michelle DuBois.