Welcome to Sofie's Choice Podcast! 5 out of 9 kids did not make it out of a house fire on Christmas Eve in 1945. Did they roll off the roof in the early hours unbeknownst to their parents? Did the Sicilian Mafia steal them away in the middle of the night? Or did they mysteriously succumb to the flames without a trace? We ain't playin' no reindeer games here; this is a REAL West Virginia mystery.

Have any spooky stories or comments about this episode? Email us at [email protected]

Follow us on social media:

Instagram: @sofieschoicepodcast

TikTok: @sofieschoicepodcast

*Theme music is sang by Sofie and edited and composed by Sam Jentink.