Betty Jo Booker's friends are expecting her at a sleepover, but she never shows up. She'd been with a friend, Paul Martin, who is also nowhere to be found. The next morning, a family driving through Spring Lake Park finds the body of the teenage boy lying in the street. Booker's body is found in a nearby community. Fear spreads throughout Texarkana as the police have very few leads.

Editor's note: This episode has been updated from its original version to correct a line about Kelly Rowland's mother's relationship with Betty Jo Booker.