Is AI art really stealing from artists—or is the backlash missing the point? In this episode of the Circle Dwellers podcast, Matt and Tim Krell offer a clear, philosophically grounded Christian perspective on AI-generated art, creativity, copyright, and human soulfulness. They dismantle common arguments against AI art (consent, job loss, environmental harm, “Miyazaki hates it”) and explain why AI is largely ethical and legal under U.S. copyright and fair use law—while still asking the more important question: is it good? Drawing on theology, aesthetics, game design, anime, and real-world AI tools, they argue that most AI art is kitsch—sentiment without sacrifice—and that true art requires human iteration, risk, and meaning that machines cannot replicate. If you’re confused or angry about AI art, worried about the future of creativity, or wondering how Christians should think about technology without fear or hype, this episode will challenge your assumptions and sharpen your thinking.