This week, we’re talking HBO’s The Jinx, Making a Murderer from Netflix, and Season 1 of Serial (a podcast from the producers of This American Life). Three addicting and binge-worthy crime documentaries about seemingly insane miscarriages of justice. Did MAM leave out damning evidence? Did the Jinx prioritize entertainment value over legal protocol? Why is the Serial subreddit so insane?

*HUGE spoilers for all 3. Shockingly, our reactions to these show’s dramatic endings actually reveal what the endings are ;)*