In this episode of She Said He Said, we’re talking about Whiplash (2014), starring Miles Teller and J.K. Simmons. One of us thinks it’s a masterpiece. The other? Not so much.

Come hang out with your favorite married couple as we bring our his-and-hers movie commentary to this intense, award-winning drama about ambition, obsession, and a seriously terrifying music teacher.

No film degrees here—just real opinions from everyday movie watchers who love to disagree (loudly).

Stream Whiplash on Amazon Prime, then join the convo. And don’t forget to follow us on Instagram for the latest updates: @shesaid.hesaid.movies.