In this Christmas Eve episode, Colleen and Tayler explore the darker side of the holiday season through true crime and folklore.

Colleen covers the murder of JonBenét Ramsey, examining the events surrounding her death on Christmas night in Boulder, Colorado, the early investigation, and how the case became one of the most infamous and controversial unsolved crimes in American history.

Tayler dives into Christmas folklore and holiday cryptids from around the world, moving beyond familiar figures like Santa Claus and Krampus. This segment explores lesser-known legends including mischievous underground creatures, winter witches who punish bad behavior, eerie bearded figures tied to holiday traditions, and other dark folklore associated with Christmas and the winter season.