As most of us are residents of a horrible island, we at VG247 have raised a suspicious eyebrow at Dead Island 2 for being not set on an island or, frankly, horrible enough for our liking. Which has led us to ask the question: what is the best game set on a horrible island? There are so many to choose from, as islands are a popular setting in video games: their size is naturally limited, so it's much easier to proportion them realistically without surrounding the map with invisible walls. Everything from Morrowind to GTA V could potentially fit the bill. But none of our panellists picked those.

In order to find out what they actually picked, you'll have to listen to it. Which is presumably what you're already doing if you're actually reading this. Image credit: Jim Purvis, creator of Thatcher's Techbase.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices