Marking the feature film debut for both screenwriter Alan Ball and director Sam Mendes, American Beauty was a cinematic sensation when it hit theaters in 1999. The movie was a critical and commercial hit, moving audiences and sweeping-up Oscars. But, as of late, it has become a popular movie to hate—often declared to be one of the most overrated best picture winners. Is that a fair assessment? Is American Beauty a millennial masterpiece—a slick work of poignant, suburban satire? Or, is it a self-important, underwhelming farce? Look closer and listen to the most beautiful podcast in the world to find out.