The Girls are joined by Jay Washington to discuss Larry Gene Bell and the disappearance of Shari Faye Smith. They also discuss the disappearances of the Millbrook Twins and the Bradley Sisters. Kristen is back with her segment, Peer Review, this time discussing twins and eugenics. They rate Shemar Moore, and discuss Grimace from the McDonald’s Gang and Tyler Perry hairstyles. Also, does Stacy have hobbit feet?

This episode can be tied to Criminal Minds season 1, episode 5: Broken Mirror.