In Episode 56, the Joey & Rhoni dive into the universal struggle of thermostat wars, with Joey recounting his "chilly" household battles and his insistence on wearing a 16-year-old high school trekking jacket. The conversation takes a turn into nostalgic food history as they review social media comments about Subway’s old "V-cut" bread technique, which the hosts hilariously describe as the "ass crack" of the bread. Joey also shares his recent experience at Pilates and spin class, where he showed up in "tight Pilates shorts" to lead by example among his NBA fantasy group.

The center piece of the episode is a blind ranking of 11 iconic songs, including hits by Michael Jackson, Britney Spears, and Queen. Tensions rise during the ranking as Rhoni makes the controversial claim that ABBA is a "niche market," leading to a heated debate over whether Dancing Queen deserves a spot in the top 10. From discussing a drunk fan at a Christmas party who congratulated them without ever listening to the show, to debating whether the Moonwalk is more iconic than the Thriller dance, this episode covers it all