Send us a text

Scotland's local democracy stands at a critical crossroads. With over 1,200 community councils supported by 10,000+ volunteers representing the most grassroots level of Scottish democracy, these institutions face unprecedented challenges that demand urgent reform. This episode explores why our 50-year-old system of local decision-making is struggling and how we can transform it to give communities genuine power over their futures.

The crisis runs deep: not a single council leader, CEO, or Chief Finance Officer expressed confidence in local government financial sustainability in 2024. But this goes beyond funding—it's about democratic representation, community empowerment, and whether local institutions can respond effectively to citizen needs. The Democracy Matters process, which engaged communities across Scotland from 2023-2024, delivered a clear message: people want greater control over decisions affecting their daily lives, but need real tools, resources, and authority to create meaningful change.

We examine the stark barriers preventing meaningful participation: administrative grants varying dramatically across Scotland, creating postcode lottery democracy; community councils lacking basic infrastructure from meeting venues to digital connectivity; and demographic profiles skewing heavily toward older, retired residents while younger people, ethnic minorities, disabled individuals, and working parents remain largely excluded from local decision-making.

The episode explores the fundamental disconnect between community challenges and available powers. Community councils find themselves consulted on minor planning applications while having no meaningful input into major infrastructure decisions, housing policies, or economic development strategies that fundamentally shape their areas. Climate change, demographic shifts, and economic inequality require coordinated responses that current structures struggle to deliver.

But hope emerges through innovation. We showcase inspiring examples: Cambuslang Community Council's successful banking hub campaign, Glasgow's creative film industry funding scheme, and West Lothian's Blueprint for Future Community Councils. Participatory budgeting initiatives demonstrate that when given genuine decision-making power, communities make thoughtful, inclusive choices reflecting local priorities.

Digital democracy offers transformative potential through Community Map Scotland's tools and online platforms making participation accessible. Local Place Plans represent a significant shift toward community-led planning, enabling residents to set development visions rather than merely responding to proposals.

The episode outlines comprehensive reform: expanding community council powers with decision-making authority and revenue-raising capabilities; standardizing funding frameworks; addressing barriers faced by underrepresented groups; youth engagement through citizenship education; and hybrid participation models maximizing inclusion.

This isn't just about community councils—it's about creating a culture where everyone has a stake in their community. Scotland needs bold democratic reform matching 21st-century challenges, giving communities real power to shape their futures.

Support the show

Come back every week for new episodes and check our our website at www.scotlandreimagined.co.uk for social and in depth articles.