That's Strike 3

Episode 6: Receiving Feedback


Listen Later

Most umpires think they're further along than they actually are. This episode is about what happens when reality checks in.

A few years ago, I asked for feedback — genuinely asked for it — thinking I was operating at a level I hadn't actually reached yet. What I got back was tough. Honest. And it forced a decision that every umpire eventually has to make: do you use the feedback to get better, or do you convince yourself the feedback was wrong?

This episode is about that moment, and what it taught me about growth in this game.

What we cover:

  • Why self-assessment as an umpire is often more generous than accurate
  • What it actually feels like to receive hard feedback you weren't ready for
  • The two roads every umpire faces when criticism lands
  • Why baseball demands continuous improvement — and why that doesn't happen without honest feedback
  • How to build a mindset that turns tough evaluations into fuel

The bottom line: You can't get better in a vacuum. The umpires who level up are the ones who learn to sit with hard feedback instead of dismissing it.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

That's Strike 3By John Telyea