On November 12, 2004, 25-year-old Katie Froeschle was working as a property claims adjuster. She was sent by her employer to a property in North Tampa, Florida, to adjust a claim for damage to the roof of a house. Katie disappeared. Thirty hours later, her body was found in a nearby river. But the killer had been careless, using a murder weapon so unique and leaving behind clues so blatant that police would have no trouble tracking him down.