On August 3, 1930, Judge Joseph F Carter left Maine, where he had been vacationing with his wife, to return to New York City for a week for work. Three days later, Joseph got dinner with his lawyer and another woman. He left the restaurant alone and was never seen or heard from again. He would eventually become known as one of the most mysterious missing person cases of the 20th century. Did Joseph choose to disappear on his own, or did something more sinister happen to him?