After you voted for Exile Island on Twitter, we rewatched all 14 episodes (and Dave even watched the mid-season recap that no one ever watches). 

In part one, we break down the top 10 through 6 players on Exile Island, which includes two players that didn't even make the merge. Find out who made the list and tune in next Sunday for our top five Exile Island players.

Highlights from this week's episode:

• Josh explains why this is the beginning of the new school era.
• One castaway could not stop repeating themselves, which is how they made the list in the first place.
• Seemingly all of Marc's coworkers watch Survivor now, but do they listen to our podcast?

Follow us on Twitter at @SurvivorTopTen for updates and live tweets, whenever Survivor starts airing again!