Grammar – What They Say
- Fabian socialism is portrayed as a covert, elite-driven movement undermining constitutional government in Britain and the United States.
- “A revolutionary secret society behind a beguiling false front of benevolence and learning.”
- The author claims Fabian socialism and communism share the same final goal, differing only in tactics.
- ⚠️ “The ultimate objective of the Fabian socialist movement is no different than the ultimate objective of the communist movement.”
- Fabian strategy is defined by gradualism, symbolized by the tortoise and the motto Festina lente (“Make haste slowly”).
- The United States is depicted as already deeply infiltrated through bureaucracy, executive agencies, and elite intellectual circles.
- “Fabians were more successful in capturing administrative than legislative posts.”
- Chapter One introduces Turtle Bay as an American Fabian hub linking intellectuals, editors, and policy influencers.
- The origins of Fabianism are traced to late-19th-century Britain, rooted in secularized, middle-class intellectual discontent.
Logic – How They Argue
- The argument relies on historical progression: Fabian success in Britain → similar methods applied in the U.S. → inevitable socialist outcome.
- ⚠️ Implied premise: What worked once will work again if unopposed.
- Fabian secrecy (“obscurantism”) is treated as proof of revolutionary intent, not prudence.
- Socialists and communists are framed as strategic partners, not rivals.
- ⚠️ “The Communists can be regarded as frontline troops while the Socialists serve as the big guns in the rear.”
- Growth in federal bureaucracy is used as quantitative evidence of Fabian advance, assuming ideological causation.
- Individual figures (e.g., Schlesinger, ADA officials) are cited to generalize about systemic capture.
Rhetoric – Why It Persuades
- Persistent war metaphors cast politics as existential struggle rather than policy debate.
- Strong elite-betrayal framing: respectable, educated figures are portrayed as masking revolutionary aims.
- ⚠️ “Endow social revolution with an aura of lofty respectability.”
- Moral absolutism: Fabianism is associated with decay and death; resistance with survival and freedom.
- Appeals to reader vigilance flatter the audience as awakened truth-seekers.
- “Instead of being anesthetized by slogans or lulled by promises.”
- Scholarly citations are blended with alarmist tone to combine authority and urgency.